Provincial Challenges: Wars and Threats Under the Flavians

 Judea - The Jewish Revolt 66-70 AD

• This was an ongoing conflict that began in 66 AD and lasted until the first year of Vespasian's reign in 70 AD
• As we have seen, Vespasian was sent out by Nero to suppress the Jewish Revolt
• The revolt was largely a result of nationalist tensions, with the Jews unable to see the tangible benefits of Roman rule and thus were opposed to the process of Romanisation that occurred elsewhere
• The culmination of the conflict occurred in 70 AD with the siege of Jerusalem, led by Titus. This brought much material wealth to Rome (allowing the Flavians to build projects such as the Colosseum) and became of great propaganda value to Vespasian and Titus

Agricola in Britain - 78-84 AD

• Britain proved both a military and political challenge for the Flavians
• The desire to maintain military auctoritas was counterweighted by a desire to successfully and effectively conduct a war in Britain
• Insurgency groups within Britain were nothing new, but they were being actively supported by tribes beyond Roman control in Scotland and Ireland
• Command of a campaign of military suppression was entrusted to Gnaeus Agricola, Tacitus' father-in-law
• The campaign would be a great success, but Agricola's actions were undermined by Domitian, who feared the growing popularity and influence Agricola gained from his conquest

The Chatti in Germany, C.85 AD

• This campaign seems to have been spurred on more because of Domitian's desire for military glory rather than any necessity
• Suetonius and Dio, who provide the most extant accounts of the campaign, are very vague in detail and thus are problematic
• They do however provide us with some details on the motives behind the campaign, as well as how the conquest was utilised by Domitian for propaganda purposes
• Interestingly, in 89 AD there was a revolt by the governor of Upper Germany, Lucius Antonius Saturninus, but this came to nothing also after weather prevented Saturninus from receiving reinforcements from the Germanic tribes on the far side of the Rhine

The Danube and the Dacians - 86-7 AD

• The Dacians proved a much more formidable threat to the Romans and Domitian's reign
• These were a tribe that occupied what is modern-day Romania
• In 85/6 AD they crossed the Danube and raided the province of Moesia (modern day Serbia, Kosovo), even managing to kill the governor and annihilate the 5th legion "Alaudae"
• Domitian despatched an equestrian, Cornelius Fuscus, to deal with the revolt, but after early successes, his army was ambushed and annihilated, with Fuscus killed
• Eventually, after a series of indecisive battles, the Romans and Dacians came to a generally inconclusive peace agreement
• This led to the emperor Trajan leading a series of campaigns in 101-2 AD to finally subdue the tribe

Activity

• Problems face by the Romans
• Judaea 66-70 AD
• Combination of religious and political fanaticism - fervent nationalistic pride amongst the Jewish people that made them resent imperial rule
• Nationalism meant that the Jewish people could not see the benefits of Imperial Rule
• Several successive revolts to try and resist Romanisation - made the province notoriously difficult to manage
• The nationalists saw foreign domination as an unqualified evil, to be resisted, and, unlike the majority of provincials elsewhere, could not recognise the benefits of Roman rule, not even on the material level of aqueducts, for example
• Britain 78-84 AD
• Cassius Dio: "war broke out again in Britain, the role of Agricola was to overrun the whole extent of enemy territory there"
• Rebellions originating from Scotland threatened Roman territories in Britain, motivated a full-scale invasion to eliminate the threat. As Dio writes, "war broke out again in Britain" (resistance was nothing new)
• Romans wished to survey the full island and ascertain its size
• Germany 85 AD
• The Chatti tribe had been a long term low-level nuisance to Roman control of the region. Though the campaign was still seen as "quite unjustified by military necessity" by Suetonius
• Once Domitian left there was a revolt led by Antonius Saturninus, governor of lower Germany (Plutarch, Suetonius) - suggest the army were not very loyal to Domitian
• Dacia 86-7 AD
• A tribe inhabiting a region that coincides roughly with modern Romania
• Cassius Dio says the "Greatest war in this period was against the Dacians"
• It appears that the Dacians invaded Moesia, perhaps fearing oppression by Domitian
• The Dacians enjoyed considerable success, killing the governor of Moesia, Oppius Sabinus and defeating the Roman legion garrisoned there
• Role of the Emperor/Other Individuals
• Judaea 66-70 AD
• Vespasian and Titus - Suetonius "sent out by Nero" before the civil war
• After Vespasian became emperor, Titus took over the Jewish legions whilst Vespasian dealt with the issues of Civil War
• Titus personally led the siege and capture of Jerusalem in 70 AD
• Cassius Dio: Titus first tried diplomacy to quell the revolt "but when this failed he resorted to military action"
• Britain 78-84 AD
• Agricola, Tacitus' father-in-law, is appointed as governor to command the army
• Tacitus: "popular opinion demanded Agricola as general, as everyone compared his fortitude and mettle with the lethargy of others"
• Agricola achieved great fame with his success, Tacitus tells us that Domitian became concerned: "it was a source of great fear to him that names of private individuals should be raised above the emperor" and "Domitian made his best effort to store up all his anger until Agricola's reputation and fame died down"
• Germany 85 AD
• Dio states that Domitian returned "never having set eyes on any warfare". Nevertheless, Domitian saw the campaign as important; he took the title Germanicus in 83 and immortalised it with coins. Tacitus compares this to Agricola, whose victory was praiseworthy while Domitian's was "a false triumph"
• Cassius Dio - one of Domitian's least attractive qualities was that he longed to be flattered, and he despised both those who flattered him and those that didn't
• Dacia 86-7 AD
• Outcome
• Britain 78-84 AD
• Germany 85 AD
• Dacia 86-7 AD

Propaganda and the Principate: The Flavians

 The Importance of Propaganda

• It could easily be argued that the Flavians created the most diverse and widespread propaganda campaign of any emperors, including Augustus
• Coinage, Architecture, Statues, Poetry, Festivals, Games, Triumphs, Religion and the Imperial Cult were all utilised to help cement the Flavian dynasty's political and social position within Rome
• The first attempts at widespread propaganda were instituted very early in Vespasian's reign, and both Titus and Domitian continued their father's campaign to ensure continued support for the Flavians

Early Religious Propaganda

• The earliest hints at propaganda come from supposed miracles that took place before Vespasian's bid for power
• Suetonius (Vespasian, 5) relates a number of portents:
• An oak tree on the Flavian estate sacred to Mars sprouted an enormous branch the day of Vespasian's birth
• When Caligula ordered Vespasian's toga be filled with mud during his tenure as Aedile, it was interpreted that one day the earth would come under his protection
• A stray once brought him a human hand it had found on a cross-road and left it under Vespasian's table whilst he ate breakfast (Manus = hand, oten used as a symbol of power)
• Another time a frenzied Ox burst into the dining hall but calmed at Vespasian's feet
• Nero once had a dream where he drove the sacred chariot of Jupiter (used in triumphs) to Vespasian's house
• A statue of Julius Caesar during the civil wars turned to face the east on it's own accord
• At the battle of Bedriacum two eagles were seen fighting overhead, before a third from the east came and drove both away
• Vespasian visited an oracle of the god Carmel in Judaea, who promised that whatever he planned or wished would be granted to him, whilst Josephus declared that the man who released him would be emperor (which ended up being Vespasian)

Early Religious Propaganda

• Though Suetonius is keen to emphasise that Vespasian and his family laughed at such religious notions, Tacitus suggests they were actively promoted by the Flavians themselves to help legitimize their position:
• "It may be that mysterious prophecies were already circulating, and that portents and oracles promised Vespasian and his sons the purple, but it was only after the rise of the Flavians that we Romans believed in such stories" - Tacitus
• Nor did everyone actively support these claims, Dio claims that Vespasian publicly healed blind men with his touch whilst in Egypt. but
• "the people of Alexandria gave him no sign of welcome; rather, they totally detested him, so much so that both privately and in public they poked fun and hurled abuse at him. They had expected to reap great rewards from having been the first to declare him emperor;" instead, they got nothing and instead had extra taxes heaped upon them" - Cassius Dio

Religious Propaganda in Rome

• In Rome the Flavians seem to have earned more immediate success with their religious propaganda:
• After celebrating the Judaean triumph Vespasian closed the Temple of Janus, the first emperor to do so since Augustus
• All three became the Pontifex Maximus during their reigns, centralising themselves in Rome's religious sphere
• Vespasian took the Censorship temporarily, whilst Domitian took the role in perpetuita
• The temples on the Capitoline Hill were restored and expanded, where "Vespasian was the first to lend a hand in clearing away the debris and carried some of it off on his own head" (Suetonius)
• The Temple of Jupiter Optimus Maximus, destroyed in the civil war, was rebuilt by Vespasian, burnt down again in 80 AD during the fire in Titus' reign and was rebuilt AGAIN by Domitian
• Vespasian was able to extend the Pomerium the sacred boundary of Rome, copying the model set by Augustus and Claudius

Art and Architecture

• Following the Augustan model of mass propagandistic messages through architecture, the Flavians built on an unprecedented scale to propagate their power to the people
• This is most famously reflected in the Colosseum, the Flavian Amphitheatre, built on the former site of Nero's Domus Aurea
• This however is just the tip of the iceberg, and all three Flavians completed works to varying success

Building Projects Activity

Complete the table

Coinage, Inscriptions

• Coinage was another easy means of disseminating images of the Flavians' achievements to the Roman people, particularly in the provinces of the emperors was harder to spread
• A few inscriptions found in Rome attest to further attempts to spread the Flavians' message. Though the sparsity of these coupled with the illiteracy of most Romans mean these were not used as thoroughly as other mediums

Poetry

• The reign of the Flavians also allowed for the production of a wide range of literature, known as the Silver Age of Latin literature (Golden Age is under Augustus)
• Tacitus, Suetonius, Pliny, Juvenal, Martial and many others we have studied all lived during the reign of the Flavians
• Unlike Augustus, there was not a centralised patronage of writers. Instead it is more likely the writers under the Flavian age were compelled to write favourably through fear/favours etc
• Some key writes linked to Flavian propaganda:
• Statius: c.45-96 AD - a poet who competed many times under the poetic competitions of Domitian, notably earning first prize in the Alban Festival and being handed the golden crown by Domitian himself. Other sources mention him being present at Domitian's banquets so clearly he was favoured by the Princeps
• Silius Italicus: c.28-103 AD - enjoyed a political career under the Julio-Claudians as a pro-Principate politician but was admired among his contemporaries for this rhetorical style and high education, and was often compared to Virgil
• Martial: c.38-102 AD - Originally from Spain, he moved to Rome inspired by the success of his countrymen, such as Seneca. Rich Roman patrons financed his works and Martial enjoyed relative popularity among the educated in Rome

Success of the Flavian Propaganda Machine?

• It is difficult to judge the success of Flavian propaganda. Some writers such as Josephus and the poets are more than laudatory towards the emperors. Others such as Tacitus and Dio are generally more pessimistic
• Perhaps the testament of later writers hint at the longevity of their achievements in the Roman mind
• Orosius, a Christian historian writing in the 5th century AD spoke of Vespasian and Titus:
• "Then, to quote the words of Cornelius Tacitus, when Augustus was old. Janus was opened once again,since fresh conquests were sought along the outer boundaries of the world, often profitably, but sometimes at considerable cost, right until the reign of Vespasian. This is according to Tacitus. But then the city of Jerusalem was captured and overthrown, as the prophets had foretold, and the Jews were eliminated by Titus, who had been chosen by God's judgement to avenge the blood of the Lord Jesus Christ. He celebrated a triumph with his father Vespasian and closed the gates of Janus"

Activity

The Flavians and the Plebs

The Flavians and the Plebs

• The Flavians' policy towards the plebs can best be summarised as a populist stance
• This has most famously been reflected in Juvenal's famous quote "panem et circenses"
•  The Flavians utilised handouts, architecture and propaganda on a massive scale, most symbolically in the Colosseum
• However, there was a need to address widespread problems that lingered after Nero's reign and the Civil War of 69 AD
• Furthermore, the Flavians needed to rebuild faith and trust in Imperial Rule

"They shed their sense of responsibility long ago, when they lost their votes, and the bribes; the mob that used to grant power, high office, the legions, everything, curtails its desires and reveals its anxiety for two things only, bread and circuses" - Juvenal

Vespasian and the Plebs

• Tacitus emphasises the acute danger Rome faced of serious famine and food shortages in 70AD:
• "Rome was tottering so dangerously that no more than ten days' corn supply was in the granaries, when supplies from Vespasian relieved the situation"
• This explains his initial absence from Rome at the time of his accession, choosing instead to wait in Alexandria to settle affairs before arriving in Rome in late 70AD
• Josephus marks this moment:
• "the people. exhausted by the miseries of civil war, were even more eager for his coming. For they believed they could now finally be freed from their suffering and could again enjoy their former peace and prosperity"
• As we have already seen, Vespasian's domestic policies were characterised by rebuilding Rome after the Civil War. This greatly earned him the affection of the plebs
• His building works, most notably the Colosseum, were a symbolic exchange from emperor to people - hence why he deliberately built the theatre on the site of Nero's old palace
• However, some of his policies, such as the Urine Tax, were considered harsh and Vespasian earned the reputation of a miser (cheapskate)

Titus and the Plebs

• Titus was remembered most notably for the 100 days of inaugural games held at the opening of the Colosseum in 80 AD
• These spectacles were unprecedented and earned Titus a reputation as an extremely generous emperor
• As we have seen, how he handled the disasters in Pompeii in 79 AD, the fire in 80 AD and the plague in 81 AD also demonstrated a close affinity between the princeps and the people
• "In these many great calamities he showed not merely the concern of an emperor, but even a father's surpassing love" - Suetonius

Domitian and the Plebs

• Though hated by the Senate, Domitian seems to have earned some degree of respect and admiration of the plebs
• As we shall see, he conducted a massive building programme not seen since the days of Augustus
• Religious festivals, mass entertainment and handouts were also utilised to placate the masses
• However, this greatly diminished Rome's public treasury, and Domitian instituted a "fiscus ludacus" - Jewish tax to "fix" the problem
• Furthermore, placation does not necessarily mean adoration. As Suetonius relates upon his death - "The people received the news of his death with indifference"

The Flavians and the Plebs Activity

• List the different ways the Flavians provided for the people
• Vespasian
• Tacitus:
• With Rome starving, Vespasian “sent his fastest ships, laden with corn, even though the seas were still rough.” No more then ten days of food were left in Rome “when Vespasian relieved the situation.”
• Presumably as a result,  Josephus writes that the people were so happy about his arrival that “they poured out of the city in such numbers that the city itself joyfully found itself empty of citizens! For those who stayed within the city were fewer than those who went out”, and anyone left came out as well once he did arrive. Everyone was delighted to see him, “uttered every type of acclamation”, and greeted him as “savior”, “benefactor”, and “the only worthy emperor of Rome.” He could barely get through the crowds and everyone was celebrating in their neighborhoods.
• Josephus was freed by Vespasian so a lot of this is likely heavily exaggerated; the people certainly seem to have been glad of his arrival, but maybe not to the extent that they all left the city to meet him
• Suetonius
• Rebuilding on a grander scale than before in many cities throughout the empire which had been burned or destroyed by earthquakes
• When an inventor visited Vespasian with a new invention that would make it easier to haul large stones, he turned the inventor down, saying "I must always ensure that the working classes earn enough money to buy themselves food" – i.e. showing the link between the building projects and jobs
• 'Behaved generously to all to all classes’- this was specifically seen with how he ‘was the first to pay teachers of Latin and Greek rhetoric a regular salary of 100,000 sesterces’.
• 'rewarded prizes to leading poets from the imperial exchequer’.
• He ensured the rebuilding of Rome after the civil wars of 68/69AD. He allowed anyone who pleased to take over vacant sites, and was the first to carry rubble off of the Capitol (perhaps an ancient photo-op moment?)
• builds the Flavian Amphitheatre (later the Colossseum). Suetonius explains that the reason was that this had been a pet project of Augustus’s. This is in stark contrast to Nero: Vespasian builds the amphitheatre on the site of the Domus Aurea.
• keen to parade his humble origins. “He had anything but a craving for outward show”.
• Nevertheless, he kept a reputation for stinginess, being called Cybiosactes by the people of Alexandria after one of their meanest kings. After his death, the famous comedian Favor mocked him while wearing his funeral mask, asking that he be pitched into the Tiber rather than paying the expenses for his funeral
• Vespasian often joked, but “most of his humour centred on the way he did business; he always tried to make his swindles sound less offensive by passing them off as jokes.” - When a statue to him was made at huge expense, he held out his hand and said “the pedestal is waiting.”
• His Urine Tax in particular was extremely unpopular, “Titus complained of the tax Vespasian had imposed on urinals. Vespasian handed him a coin which had been part of the first day’s proceeds; ‘does it smell bad, my son?’ he asked. ‘No, father.’ ‘That’s odd: it comes straight from the urinal!’”
• Vespasian needed 40 billion sesterces to “put the commonwealth back on its feet”, so his stinginess and emphasis on heavy taxation may have been justified. Shows however that just because something is good for the people does not mean that they will like him for it!
• Titus
• How he dealt with disasters during his reign reflected his legacy
• Fire in Rome
• Cassius Dio: he repaired and rebuilt areas destroyed by fire out of his own existing resources rather than taxes
• Suetonius: he auctioned his own property to pay for rebuilding rather than taxes “this has ruined me!”
• Plague
• Suetonius: Titus attempted to control the plague by every possible means, both human and divine – ensuring all proper religious ceremonies were performed
• Vesuvius Eruption 79AD
• Suetonius:
• He set up a board of ex-consuls to relieve distress in Campania and devoted the property of those that had died in the eruption and left no heirs to the rebuilding of the cities affected.
• claims that his concern resembled that of a father rather than an emperor
• “Titus maintained that no-one ought to go away disappointed after an audience with the Emperor.” never let a petitioner leave without some hope that his request would be favourably considered. Emperors had to deal with a huge amount of daily correspondence and petititions from all ranks of society, which was why they employed freedmen to look after this aspect of their work. It would have been hard for people to gain access to the emperor, especially plebeians, so Titus is showing great political skills here in ensuring that people leave with a sense that they are getting somewhere.
• Domitian
• Chronicle of 354
• “He gave three handouts of 75 denarii. By this emperor many public works were constructed”, including 7 halls, pepper warehouses, the granaries of Vespasian, the Temple of Castor and Minerva, the Capena Gate, the Temple of the Flavian Family, the Temple of the Divi, the Temples of Isis and Serapis, the Temple of Minerva and Chalchis, the Odeum, the Old Minucia, the Stadium, the Baths of Titus and Trajan, the amphitheatre up to its shields, the Temple of Vespasian and Titus, the Capitolium, the Senate House, 4 gladiatorial schools, the Palatine Palace, the Meta Sudans and the Pantheon. (Jeez so many temples, in hindsight I could've just written "lots and lots of temples")
• Suetonius
• He restored many important buildings that had been gutted by the fire including the Capitol
• Made a number of social innovations - cancelled the distribution of food parcels, restoring the custom of holding formal dinners - (less practival but would gain him more popularity)
• Added two new teams of chariot drivers
• Castration was now strictly prohibited. The price of eunuchs remaining in slave dealers’ hands was officially controlled.
• "raised the legionaries' pay from 900 to 1,200 sesterces a year"
• On three occasions distributed three gold pieces a head (compared to Nero’s 40 this is quite measly). The at the Feast of the Seven Hills, large hampers of food for Senators and Knights were distributed but smaller ones for the Plebs. And like Gaius, he scatters gifts for the Plebs to scramble for. But when most of the tokens fall in the plebeian seats, he makes sure that the Knights and Senators get 500 tokens for each class too.
• A number of significant public buildings, e.g. the Stadium on the Campus Martius, a new Forum (later called the Forum of Nerva, the next emperor), and an artificial lake for sea battles.
• When there were grain shortages in Italy, Domitian suspected it was because farmers were cutting crops in favour of wine production. He therefore introduced a vine-edict banning the planting of any more vineyards in Italy to encourage grain production, and set aside land in the provinces to recover the losses. Suetonius suggests he did not get very far with this edict, but it still earned him ridicule - – his “Vine Edict” as it was called earned him the nickname of a “Vine-Eating Goat” and earned him unpopularity with the elites who’s vineyards had been upended by the edict. 
• What types of games were held for the people?
• Vespasian
• Suetonius:
• "When the Theatre of Marcellus opened again after Vespasian had built its new stage, he revived the former musical performances"
• Proved himself a devoted patron of the arts and science.
•  Awarded prizes to leading poets and to artists as well, notably the ones who refashioned the Venus Of Cos and the Colossus.
• He presented Apelles the tragic actor with 400,000 sesterces, Terpnus and Diodorus the lyre players with 200,000 sesterces, and several others with 100,00 sesterces the lowest being 40,000. 
• He ordered a great number of formal dinners on a lavish scale to support the dealers in provisions. 
• On the Saturnalia (Roman Christmas) he gave party favours to the male dinner party guests and he did the same for women on the Kalends of March. 
• Titus
• Suetonius:
• “no emperor could have been less of a robber than Titus” – alluding to his unmatched generosity from entertainment
•  “At the dedication of the Amphitheatre and the Baths, which had been hastily built beside it, Titus provided a most lavish gladiatorial show; he also staged a sea fight on an old artificial lake, and when the water had been let out he used the basin for further gladiatorial contests and a wild-beast hunt, 5,000 beasts of different sorts dying in a single day” – somebody call PETA! “On one occasion before a gladiatorial show he promised to forgo his own preferences and let the audience choose what they liked best… Yet he openly acknowledged his partisanship for the Thracian school of gladiators, and would gesture and argue vociferously with the crowd on the subject, though never losing his dignity” – (trying to give off his man-of-the people image)
• Cassius Dio
• even suggests the Colosseum floor itself was flooded to stage a naval battle that was meant to mimic the battle between Corinth and Corcyra before the Peloponnesian War. Here is the full passage (though you don’t need to know all of it!):
•  “Most that he did was not characterized by anything noteworthy, but in dedicating the hunting-theatre and the baths that bear his name he produced many remarkable spectacles. There was a battle between cranes and also between four elephants; animals both tame and wild were slain to the number of nine thousand; and women (not those of any prominence, however) took part in despatching them. As for the men, several fought in single combat and several groups contended together both in infantry and naval battles. For Titus suddenly filled this same theatre with water and brought in horses and bulls and some other domesticated animals that had been taught to behave in the liquid element just as on land. He also brought in people on ships, who engaged in a sea-fight there, impersonating the Corcyreans and Corinthians; and others gave a similar exhibition outside the city in the grove of Gaius and Lucius, a place which Augustus had once excavated for this very purpose. There, too, on the first day there was a gladiatorial exhibition and wild-beast hunt, the lake in front of the images having first been covered over with a platform of planks and wooden stands erected around it. On the second day there was a horse-race, and on the third day a naval battle between three thousand men, followed by an infantry battle. The "Athenians" conquered the "Syracusans" (these were the names the combatants used), made a landing on the islet and assaulted and captured a wall that had been constructed around the monument. These were the spectacles that were offered, and they continued for a hundred days; but Titus also furnished some things that were of practical use to the people.”
• “He would throw down into the theatre from aloft little wooden balls variously inscribed, one designating some article of food, another clothing, another a silver vessel or perhaps a gold one, or again horses, pack-animals, cattle or slaves. Those who seized them were to carry them to the dispensers of the bounty, from whom they would receive the article named.”
• Domitian
• Suetonius
• In honour of Jupiter Capitolinus he founded a festival of music, horsemanship and athletics to be held every five years, and awarded far more prizes than is customary nowadays.
• “in the Amphitheatre but also in the Circus, where besides the usual two- and four-horse chariot races he staged a double battle, with both infantry and cavalry; in the Amphitheatre he presented a sea fight as well as wild-beast hunts and gladiatorial shows, some by torchline and where women as well as men took part” Held Saecular games, fixing their date by Augustus’ old reckoning and ignoring Claudius’ more recent celebration of them.
• “the Quaestorian Games which he had revived, and he allowed the people to demand a combat between two pairs of gladiators from his own troop”
• Cassius Dio
• “He put on extravagant spectacle, of which we have no record of anything happening that was historically significant except for a girls’ foot race. After that he put on innumerable contests as part of what he presented as victory celebrations." 
• "These included battles in the Circus, both infantry and cavalry, and at a newly constructed location he staged a naval battle also.” (At this location, he forbade the contestants of spectators from leaving during a violent storm, and many resultingly became sick and died while he changed into thicker cloaks – as consolation, he held a dinner party.) 
• “There were often all-night games, as well, and on some occasions he would stage fights between women and dwarfs.” 
• A lake was dug at his orders close to the Tiber, and used for almost full-scale naval battles. 
• (Why is he fixated on such elaborate, sometimes novel, and definitely excessive forms of entertainment? Well who has just been regarded as Rome’s most generous emperor for his 100 days of games to inaugurate the Colosseum? Jealous brother much!!!)
• What do you think accounts for the Flavians' success in maintaining the support of the people?

The Princeps and the Senate: The Flavians and Rome

 Example of Senatorial Career

This includes many of the available senatorial posts, along with many other optional offices such as curator of the Tiber and the city sewers which became available once a senator had reached praetorian or consular rank

As with many such inscriptions, the offices are listed in reverse order of how important they were considered to be - i.e the consulship comes first, because this was considered the peak of a senatorial career, while the last office listed is a minor legal administrative position

(See older posts for the various senatorial positions)

The Senate by AD 70

• The senate had lost much of its influence by Vespasian's succession in AD 70
• The facade that Augustus had created to mask his own position and power behind a Republican framework had all but dropped. Everyone knew that the Princeps was a monarch
• The Senators themselves had never experienced anything other than emperors also, as Tacitus puts it "how many were left who had seen the Republic?"
• Yet the Senate still held a significant purpose within the Principate. They were the key administrators of the vast empire, with consuls, praetors, proconsuls and aediles still fulfilling their responsibilities

Vespasian and the Senate

• The Senate's declining influence had rendered them ineffective and immobilised, yet Vespasian appears to have desired for the Senate to retain some of its use, even if only as administrative assistants to the Princeps
• In 73-4 AD Vespasian adopted the Censorship, allowing him to promote chosen individuals into the Senate (adlection)
• Adlected individuals seem particularly to be drafted from the provinces, perhaps reflecting a wider participation of the empire in governance
• Vespasian attempted to consult and curry favour with the Senate, either by himself or through his sons
• However, he also maintained a number of imperial freedmen to help with the administrative needs of the empire

Titus and the Senate

• Few serious changes due to his short-lived reign
• Appears to have continued Vespasian's desire to establish a functional autocracy - with defined roles for both the Senate and Princeps
• The sources do emphasise Titus' desire to respect the Senate, in particular his mercy and clemency which was considered unique for an emperor

Domitian and the Senate

• Whilst Titus and Vespasian sought to placate the Senate and create a functional and practical working relationship, Domitian appears to have deviated from these plans
• Crucially, Domitian formalised far more clearly the Consilium Principis, the imperial council of selected amici (friends) who acted as advisors to the emperor
• Though this system had been created by Augustus and existed under every emperor, it was Domitian who most openly admitted their importance and more blatantly preferred monarchy and autocracy over working with the Senate
• Domitian fanned the flames of his autocracy by openly accepting the accusations of the delatores and beginning again the bloody process of maiestas that had earned Tiberius such hatred from the Patricians
• He openly boasted of his role as Censoria Perpetuita (Perpetual Censor), allowing him to both scrutinise and overhaul the Senate at his own whim

Activity:

• Vespasian
• Reforms/changes made to the senatorial order or its roles
• Suetonius
• "He reformed the senatorial and equestrian orders, now weakened by frequent murders and long-term neglect"
• "Replacing any undesirables with the most eligible Italian and provincial candidates" - continuing a policy of adlection (enlisting) provincials to the Senate begun by Claudius, this would help the Senate become more representative of the entire empire rather than just the Roman elite
• The emperor's attitude towards the senate
• Suetonius
• "in order to define clearly the difference between those orders as one of status rather than privilege" - he said this during a dispute between a senator and an equestrian: "no abuse may be offered a senator, though it may be returned when given." - shows a desire for the Senate to retain their privileged position, perhaps very important considering the Flavians were an Equestrian family
• Cassius Dio
• "He would regularly attend the senate and was open to discussion with members on any topic...any despatches he could not read himself, beacuse of his age, he usually asked his sons to read for him, thus showing in even such minor details a meticulous respect for the senate"
• The emperor's attitude towards maiestas
• Suetonius
• he hated it when a person was to receive 'the extreme penalty' often times weeping. Thus with Helvidius Priscus who was to be put to death, he tried after this penalty to stop the execution but was too late to change the order
• "No innocent party was ever punished during his reign"
• Titus
• Reforms/changes made to the senatorial order or its roles
• Suetonius
• "He chose commissioners by lot from among the ex-consuls for the relief of Campania; and the property of those who lost their lives by Vesuvius" - shows a desire to include the Senate in administrative tasks
• The emperor's attitude towards the senate
• The emperor's attitude towards maiestas
• Suetonius
• "one of the worst features of Roman life at the time was the licence ling enjoyed by informers and their managers" [on Titus' orders] after these had been soundly beaten in the Forum with scourges and cudgels, and finally left in procession of the amphitheatre, he had some of them put up and sold into slavery, and others deported to the wildest islands
• He also prevented anyone from being tried for the same crime twice, and imposed limits on the time that inquiries could be made into the status of dead people
• He could not bring himself to use execute senators, even those who had committed open plots - once when two Senators were convicted of plotting against the emperor Titus instead invited them into the imperial box to inspect the swords at a gladiator match

• Domitian
• Reforms/changes made to the senatorial order or its roles
• Suetonius
• "He personally urged the tribunes of the people to charge a corrupt aedile with extortion and to petition the senate for a special jury in the case"
• he was "conscientious" about justice and levels of justice rose to "unprecedently high levels"
• He came down heavily on authors who lampooned men and women, expelled a senator for being "overfond of acting and dancing", "struck an equestrain from the jury roll because he had divorced his wife on a charge of adultery and then taken her back again" and sentenced members of both orders under the Scantinian Law
• "It was his ruling that if a juryman were proved to have taken bribes, all his colleagues must be penalized as well as himself"
• The emperor's attitude towards the senate
• Tacitus
• "Domitian no longer allowed any interval or breathing space but destroyed the state as if by one, continuous assault!
• "It was some consolation that Agricola did not see the senate house besieged and the senators blocked in by armed men; nor the murder of so many former consuls in one massacre; nor the exile or banishment of so many noble ladies"
• "The old have reached almost the limits of the span of life in silence" under Domitian - Tacitus is glad to have composed an account of "our former slavery"
• Tacitus extolls Nerva's virtues for undoing such terror, but "does it matter if, for fifteen years, a large part of our human lifespan, most have perished, but the vicissitudes of fate, and all the most prominent, by the emperor's savagery?"
• The emperor's attitude towards maiestas
• Suetonius
• "He put many senators to death, three for conspiracy but others for trivial reasons;"
• Aelius Lamia was killed for the comments he made - after his wife was taken by Domitian, he remarked "I'm in training" when someone praised his voice, and when encouraged by Titus to marry again he responded "you're not wanting a wife too, are you?"
• Salvius Cocceianus was killed for still celebrating his uncle, Otho's, birthday, and Mettius Pompusianus for having an "imperial horoscope", carrying around a map of the world and speeches by kings and generals extracted from Livy, and naming two of his slaves Mago and Hannibal
• Sallustius Lucullus had offended Domitian by calling a new type of lance 'the Lucullan'
• Junius Rusticus by calling Thrasea Paetus and Helvidius Priscus the "most virtuous of men" (this incident led to Domitian banishing all philosophers from Italy)
• After his victory in the civil war he became even more cruel, and to discover any conspirators who were in hiding, tortured many of the opposite party by a new form of inquisition, inserting fire in their privates; and he cut off the hands of some of them
• Tacitus
• "But before long our hands led Helvidius into prison; the expressions of Maurcus and Rusticus condemned us; we were drenched in the innocent blood of Senecio. Even Nero looked away when he ordered crimes and did not watch them, whereas an especial part of the miseries under Domitian was to watch them and to be observed our sighs were noted down and his savage and purple face (which saved him from blushing for shame) was enough to mark out all those who had turned 

Resistance to the Flavians: Vespasian

• Though the Flavians enjoyed (relative) political stability, opposition from within the Senatorial body did occasionally rear its head
• The Stoics:
• Under Vespasian a group of self-identified Stoic Senators voiced open opposition to the notion of emperor
• These rallied behind Helvidius Priscus, the son-in-law of famous senator Thrasea Patus
• Priscus and the Stoics preached a nostalgic (probably not practical) Republicanism that was in direct contradiction of the Flavian's aims of a functional autocracy
• Priscus himself would eventually be exiled and executed, but his martyrdom became a figurehead for other Stoic Senators, leading to their persecution under Domitian

Resistance to the Flavians: Domitian

• Direct conspiracies and opposition to the emperor are rare in this period, but under Domitian, the charges of maiestas became prevalent again
• Our sources are keen to emphasis a number of atrocities committed by Domitian against the Senate, explained by many of their own first-hand experiences under the emperor (i.e Tacitus)
• However, Domitian's reign was ended not by the Senate, but by his own conspiring courtiers. The Senate only took part in his damnatio memoriae when it was certain he was dead

Denarius of Domitian, 85 AD, proudly boasting of his acceptance of the Censoria Perpetuita, giving him the right to overhaul the Senate indefinitely. The goddess displayed is Minerva, whom Domitian adopted as his patron goddess

Task One: The Stoics

• How are Helvidius Priscus and the Stoics described by the sources?
• Tacitus
• "As a young man he devoted his notable talents to higher scholarship, not, like many, to clothe a life of idleness under a pretentious name, but to be better able to withstand the vicissitudes of public office."
• "He followed those teachers of philosophy who hold that virtuous conduct is the only good; that wrong-doing is shameful; that power, noble birth and other things outside what one can control should be counted as neither good nor wrong."
• "While still a quaestor he was chosen by Thrasea Paetus as his son-in-law, and from his father-in-law's character he learnt freedom (libertas) above all"
• "As a citizen, senator, husband, son-in-law, friend he was just in all his duties in life, uncorrupted by wealth, resolute in righteousness, dauntless in the face of fear."
• "There were people who thought he was too keen to seek fame, since even philosophers rid themselves, last of all, of desire for glory."
• Cassius Dio
• "Instead he constantly insulted him. For this on one occasion he was arrested by the tribunes, and placed in custody with their deputies. Vespasian was greatly distressed by this and left the senate-house in tears. His only comment was that, "my son is going to be my successor; no one else."
• Suetonius
• "Although Helvidius Priscus 757 was the only man who presumed to salute him on his return from Syria by his private name of Vespasian, and, when he came to be praetor, omitted any mark of honour to him, or even any mention of him in his edicts, yet he was not angry, until Helvidius proceeded to inveigh against him with the most scurrilous language. (456) Though he did indeed banish him, and afterwards ordered him to be put to death, yet he would gladly have saved him notwithstanding, and accordingly dispatched messengers to fetch back the executioners; and he would have saved him, had he not been deceived by a false account brought, that he had already perished. He never rejoiced at the death of any man; nay he would shed tears, and sigh, at the just punishment of the guilty.
• What does Cassius Dio tell us of Vespasian's attitude towards other Stoics?
• There were many others also, among them Demetrius the Cynic, who were encouraged by so-called Stoic teachings to promote to the public at large many ideas, wholly inappropriate to current circumstances, under the guise of philosophical instruction."
• Mucianus persuaded Vespasian to expel all such persons from the city
• "Vespasian's immediate reaction was to expel all the philosophers from Rome, except Musonius; with Demetrius and Hostilianus he went further, deporting them to imprisonment on islands. Hostilianus happened to be holding a conversation with someone, when he heard of the decision for his exile. Far from refraining from any further discussion, he continued to denounce autocracy even more vigorously. All the same, he lost no time in leaving Rome."
• "Demetrius, by contrast, even then refused to give an inch. Vespasian had a message sent to him to the effect that "you are doing everything you can to make me execute you. But I don't kill yapping dogs."

• What does Cassius Dio tells us of Domitian's persecution of philosophers?

• "He killed Arulenus Rusticus for being a philosopher and for calling Thrasea Paetus "holy"; and Herennius Senecio, because in the whole of a long life he had failed to campaign for any office after his quaestorship, and had written a biography of Helvidius Priscus. Many others died for the self same offence of philosophising, and any that remained were all exiled from Rome once more."

• What does Tacitus tell us of Domitian's oppression of free speech?
• "We have certainly produced a great example of passiveness; just as a former age saw the last word in freedom, so we have seen the last word in servility, since cross-examinations have robbed us of even the exchange of speaking and listening. We would have lost memory itself, alongside speech, if it had been equally possible for us to forget as to be silent."

Task Two: Resistance to the Flavians

• Vespasian
• Cassius Dio
• “there was also a conspiracy against the emperor, led by Alienus and Marcellus”
• These two plotted to assassinate Vespasian despite him giving them “every kind of honour”
• Suetonius
• "that even after constant conspiracies were made against him he had the assurance to say to the senate that either his sons would succeed him or no one would"
• Titus 
• Suetonius
• "Two men of patrician rank being convicted of aspiring to the empire, he only advised them to desist, saying, "that the sovereign power was disposed of by fate," and promised them, that if there was anything else they desired of him, he would grant it. He also immediately sent messengers to the mother of one of them, who was at a great distance, and in deep anxiety about her son, to assure her of his safety. Nay, he not only invited them to sup with him, but next day, at a show of gladiators, purposely placed them close by him; and handed to them the arms of the combatants for his inspection."

• Domitian
• Cassius Dio
• Domitian almost put Ursus to death for not showing "manifest delight" at his achievements
• Domitian had some of the "leading citizens" murdered, and confiscated someone's goods because they buried one of his victims
• Domitian expelled Caecillius Rufinus from the senate for acting in pantomimes, and he killed Arulenus Rusticus for being a philosopher and calling Thraesea Patus 'holy'
• Then there was a sophist called Maternus, whom Domitian executed for criticising tyrants as part of a rhetorical exercise
• Domitian killed Herrenius Senecio because he didn't run for office after his quaestorship and wrote a biography of Helvidius Priscus
• Juventius Celsus was charged with conspiracy against Domitian but escaped by grovelling and promising an investigation into the conspiracy, which was unsuccessful, he managed to create excuses for the lack of success until Domitian's death.
• Julius Calvaster, a military tribune with senatorial ambitions. he could not think of any way of escaping a charge of conspiracy. So he stated that they had in fact met for sexual intercourse — and certainly his good looks made the claim plausible. And so he was acquitted
• Domitian treated all senatorial supporters and critics the same: “the former because they were clearly seeking to ingratiate themselves with him, the latter because they seemed to view him with contempt.”
• "Many men and women among the wealthy classes were punished for adultery, some of the women being the victims of rape by Domitian himself. Many others were fined or murdered on a variety of charges. One woman was tried and put to death for undressing in front of a statue of Domitian; another man for consorting with astrologers."
• “They were both charged with atheism, an offence which had shipwrecked many of those who had been condemned for sailing too close to Jewish customs.” These were Flavius Clemens and his wife Flavia Domitilla.                                        
• The consequences: “Domitilla herself was merely exiled to the island of Pandateria. But Glabrio, Traianus' fellow consul, was charged with the same offences as many others, but specifically also with fighting in the arena with wild animals, and executed.”
• "In this period a certain Antonius was the governor of Germany. He staged a revolt against Domitian, but Lucius Maximus attacked and destroyed him. In itself this victory was of little merit or significance — after all, unexpected success is not unusual in military campaigns, and of course Lucius' soldiers were part and parcel of that victory. But Lucius also burnt all the documents that were found in Antonius' storage chests, an act which showed that he was relatively indifferent to his own safety compared with his desire to protect others from being informed against. Such an action seems to me so wholly admirable that I cannot find words with which to express my admiration."
• Suetonius
• Got rid of many of the leading aristocrats on a "range of pretexts"
• Punished the Vestal Virgins on a charge of them having sex
• Helvius Agrippa was so shocked by the barbarity that he died of shock in the senate house
• Ex-consuls Civica Cerealis, Salvidienus Orfitus and Acilius Glabrio (who was in exile) were all killed for plotting revolution, while others were killed by Domitian “on whatever charge, however trivial.”:
• Aelius Lamia for joking about Domitian stealing his wife.
• Salvius Cocceianus for celebrating the birthday of Otho, his uncle
• Mettius Pompusianus for having an imperial horoscope, carrying around a map of the world and speeches from kings and generals from Livy, and naming two slaves Mago and Hannibal.
• Sallustius Lucullus, governor of Britain, for naming a new type of lance the ‘Lucullan’ after himself.
• Junius Rusticus for praising Thrasea Paetus and Helvidius Priscus
• The younger Helvidius for parodying Domitian and his wife on stage.
• And Flavius Sabinus, one of his cousins, for announcing him as emperor-elect rather than consul on the day of consular elections. 
• "Flavius Sabinus too, one of his cousins, because on the day of the consular elections the crier had inadvertently announced him to the people as emperor elect, instead of consul."

The Flavians

 The Situation After Vitellius

• Following Vitellius' death, the Flavian supporters took control of the turbulent situation in Rome
• Vespasian remained in Egypt for a long time, ensuring the situation in the provinces stabilised
• In Rome, Mucianus and Domitian took control of the government, of the latter "While not yet prepared to give his mind to his official responsibilities, he was already playing the part of an emperor's son so far as seducing girls and women went" - Tacitus
• Titus remained in Judaea, crushing the last of the Jewish revolt and preparing for an assault upon Jerusalem
• Antonius Primus, the "rogue general" who had seized Rome unexpectedly, helped himself to treasure from the imperial palace by humbly stood down when Mucianus arrived, and gave over his support to Vespasian

The Accession of Vespasian, 69-70 AD

• Vespasian was a civil war emperor, technically no different than the others, but certain hopeful signs proved the difference between Vespasian and his short-lived predecessors:
• Vespasian seemed to be aiming for stability and restoration
• Vespasian seemed willing to work with the senate
• Vespasian and his sons formed a simple, recognisable dynasty
• "Vespasian spoke [to the senate] as if he were truly emperor, modestly concerning himself, and on public issues like a statesman. The senate in its turn showed a proper respect. By its decree Vespasian received the consulship with his son Titus as colleague, and Domitian was accorded the praetorship and the powers of a consul" - Tacitus
• Thus began the twenty-seven year Flavian Dynasty of emperors

Making an Emperor: Epigraphic Evidence

• One key piece of evidence related to Vespasian'a accession comes in the form of a bronze tablet found in Rome, the "Lex De Imperio Vespasiani" (The Law Concerning the Power of Vespasian)
• The tablet is a senatorial inscription, of which only the latter half has survived
• The tablet details the Senatorial bill that was put to the Roman people, granting Vespasian the powers of emperor

Activity

• What powers were granted to Vespasian according to this inscription?
• Had the right to "conclude treaties with whomever he wishes"
• Tribunician power
• Basically amalgamated the powers of all previous emperors
• Previous powers that other emperors had would be more powerful under this new political context
• Some of the powers are (perhaps deliberately) quite vague, which allowed Vespasian more room to push the boundaries of what these powers could do
• Historical continuity - he is not completely abandoning the traditions of the empire
• What emperors does Vespasian model himself on? Which emperors are omitted? Why do you think this might be?
• Relied on the legal precedence laid down by the Julio-Claudian emperors, which means the senate would have been comfortable with it. Emphasises the legality of his position through being decreed powers by the senate - Acta Senatus
• Modelled himself on the "good" emperors - Augustus, Tiberius and Claudius, while notably excluding Caligula and Nero

Vespasian 69-79 AD: A Reign of Restoration

• Vespasian provided much-needed leadership and stability after the tumultuous years before
• He reformed Rome's financial system and saved it from bankruptcy
• He reorganised the Senate, removing rivals and adding to his allies
• He made some changes to provincial organisation, taking charge of rich provinces such as Greece and Macedonia

Propaganda Campaign

• Vespasian needed to ensure the legitimacy of his power, so he undertook a large propaganda campaign to secure this
• Coins were minted celebrating peace
• Use of the Imperial Cult in the provinces
• Most famously, the construction of the Colosseum - also known as the Flavian Amphitheatre
• The Amphitheatre was built on the site of Nero's much hated Domus Aurea, a sign of a changing relationship between emperor and people

Titus AD 79-81 

• Renown
• When Vespasian died in AD 79, rule passed to his son, Titus - the Flavian Dynasty was established
• Titus was also a renowned military commander, who had served with his father
• However, despite his later successful reign he had a reputation in his youth of brutality and recklessness
• A Good Emperor
• As emperor, he completed the construction of the Colosseum (Vespasian had died before its completion)
• His reign was short, and so no long term policies were enacted, however, his clemency was shown with how he dealt with two major disasters during his reign: the eruption of Vesuvius and a second fire in Rome
• Titus offered generous relief for both of these disasters, which earned him admiration from all in Rome
• After barely two years, Titus died of a fever, and was succeeded by his younger brother, Domitian

Domitian AD 81-96

• Domitian had lived in the shadow of his far more successful brother
• As emperor, he modelled himself on Augustus and Tiberius and fostered a policy of religious, military and cultural propaganda, which earned him the love of the common people
• He initiated a massive building programme to restore the damaged city of Rome
• His general, Agricola (Tacitus' father-in-law) subdued large parts of Scotland

A Divisive Emperor

• Though popular with the people, he was particularly paranoid of threats to his power, especially from the Senate
• Because of this, he stripped the Senate of most of its responsibilities, and persecuted Senators under the guise of maiestas trials
• Eventually, a conspiracy within the palace was organised by court officials
• Domitian was murdered by one of his freedmen, Stephanus. He had concealed a dagger on his person by faking an injury and wearing a bandage with the weapon inside
• The Senate rejoiced at his death, and passed a damnatio memoriae on his memory: coins and statues were melted, and he was erased from all public records
• Writers who had lived through his reign, such as Tacitus, Suetonius, Cassius Dio and the Younger Pliny all recorded histories portraying him as a ruthless tyrant

The Character of the Flavians

• As with the Julio-Claudians, the sources on the personalities of our three Flavian emperors are problematic at best. Tacitus sums up the situation:
• "Truth too, suffered in more ways than one. To an understandable ignorance of policy, which now lay outside public control, was in due course added a passion for flattery, or else a hatred for autocrats" - Tacitus
• What can we learn of the emperors' personalities?
• What seems to be the attitude of each emperor towards ruling Rome?

Vespasian

• Suetonius
• he would rise early to deal with all official correspondences - motivated, hardworking - clearly takes his job very seriously
• He never bore grudges against people, he only condemned Helvidius Priscus after a long while of bearing his criticisms, and he would often weep when he needed to condemn people to death  - patient and compassionate
• he ensured food prices were kept low for the common people. When an inventor met with Vespasian to offer a design for a new mechanism to carry heavy loads up hills, he generously rewarded them but turned the offer down - he claimed he wanted to ensure the common people always had a means of employment - cares more for the people than money - he took a great deal of interest in protecting the welfare of the people of the empire
• Source points out his sense of humour - Salvius Liberalis once made him laugh by asking "does the emperor really care or not whether Hipparchus is or is not worth a million gold?" and his response to Demetrius the Cynic who kept yelling at him was "good dog" - absolute joker
• He had a very dry, rough sense of humour and spoke with a common accent - down to earth
• He was the first to pay teachers an annual salary of 100,000 sesterces - further evidence of his concern for Rome's wellbeing
• "his one serious failing was avarice" - he would stockpile goods and resell them at a higher price, he would extract fees from candidates for public office, would deliberately pick candidates who were wealthy so that he could sponge money off of them - called them his "sponges" - deliberately picked the greediest procurators so he could later charge them with extortion - he justified his greed by claiming that he was restoring the treasury that had been depleted from the civil war. He claimed he needed 40 billion sesterces to restore Rome's finances
• he neither claimed Tribunician Power nor Father of the Country until later in his reign - he does not want to exercise the extreme powers of emperor, giving more space for the Senate to take charge
• Cassius Dio
• He behaved more as a private citizen than as an emperor. He would greet everyone in the streets and would fine publicly rather than in the palace, and would allow an audience with anyone - shows him to be open and considers everyone's say, not just the senate
• he showed a "meticulous" respect for the Senate - he always ensured that he would take seriously all the Senate's recommendations, and when he himself could not attend meetings would send his sons in his place - treats the senate as colleagues in power rather than his inferiors and wants the to be involved in policy making
• In all public expenditure, he was incredibly generous, but in his private life he was economical to the extreme - shows his humility - he doesn't look down on the plebs
• He once wept when meeting with the Senate who would not listen to his decisions, his only words were "my son is going to be my successor, no one else" - clear that Vespasian is ensuring that he will establish a dynasty when he dies

Titus

• Suetonius/Cassius Dio:
• both emphasise that he was cruel and excessive - he held outrageous parties with his extravagant friends, kept a troupe of toyboys and eunuchs, and had an infamous affair with Queen Berenice. 
• His accession was the least well-received in Rome. The people expected another Nero.
•  As prince, he was in charge of the Praetorian Guard, a position usually reserved for the Equestrians. If anyone aroused his suspicions he would quickly dispatch soldiers to execute them - Vesapasian did this to ensure the loyalty of the Praetorian Guard and to secure his own safety, as Galba and other emperors had been removed by the Praetorians
• Suetonius
• Once he ascended to the throne it turned out he was in fact "no monster but an exceptionally noble character"
• he always ensured he would help someone every day, and when he could not achieve this he said "my friends, I have wasted a day" - takes his role very seriously and sees said role as helping people
• No emperor could have been less of a robber than Titus. He showed great respect for private property, held impressive games (including a naval battle on an artificial lake and a hunt for 5,000 beasts where he allowed the crowd to choose their preference of gladiators). He also used his public baths to keep up with people - seems to show a genuine concern for the wellbeing of Rome's citizens, rather than just acting helpful for the sake of political expediency
• After a fire in Rome, he auctioned his own property to pay for rebuilding rather than taxes - "this has ruined me"
• When there was a plague he attempted to control it by every possible means, both human and divine, ensuring that all proper religious ceremonies were performed
• After Vesuvius erupted in 79 AD he set up a board of consuls chosen by lot to relieve the distress and he redirected state funds from any inheritances to rebuild the cities
• his concern for the people during these crises was more like "the concerns of a father than an emperor"
• he invited conspirators to the games, and let them inspect the weapons with him - shows that he trusts the Senators. He is demonstrating his forgiveness of their plots by allowing them to inspect the (sharp) weapons with him
• he was particularly angry at the Informers (Delatores). He even had them publicly flogged and some were sold into slavery - the senate would have loved this as the Delatores were the scourge of the senate and the main reason behind maiestas trials
• he was "naturally kind-hearted" and could not bring himself to punish his brother Domitian, who constantly plotted against him
• Titus swore he would rather "die than take a life"
• Cassius Dio
• he dealt with the fire in Rome by fixing the ruined areas out of his own existing resources rather than with taxes
• during his reign, no senator was put to death. Even though he was the target of conspiracies
• he broke off his relationship with Queen Berenice - shows his dedication to Rome over his own personal desires
• Tacitus
• he lived a life of pleasure in his youth but "proved more self-disciplined during his own reign than his father's". He was concerned to "live up to his new position by cutting a fine character and showing an enterprise in arms" he had a "polite and affable manner"

All the sources acknowledge that once Titus became emperor he stepped up to his responsibilities, and his turn of character was dramatic but of course, welcomed.

Cassius Dio goes against the other sources by claiming that if he had reigned longer his negative side would have shown more. His untimely death after just two years meant he died before his true reputation could be revealed

Domitian

• Suetonius
• "we have no cause to be ashamed of the Flavian record, though it is generally admitted that Domitian's cruelty and greed justified his assassination". Summarises the historical perceptions of the Flavians at the time. Vespasian and Titus were admired, but Domitian was condemned - (his increasing use of maiestas as a result of his greed, paranoia and cruelty would lead to his condemnation by the ancient sources such as Tacitus and Pliny the Younger - senators who survived his reign)
• "lack of funds made him greedy and the fear of assassination made him cruel"
• "he never stopped plotting, secretly or openly, against his brother"
• he launched a "quite unnecessary" campaign into Gaul and Germany to "acquire a reputation that would compare favourably with his brother" - emphasises his feelings of inadequacy in comparison to his brother, and how this led him to conduct unnecessary military campaigns
• wheneber Titus and Vespasian went out in their sedan chairs, Domitian had to follow behind in a litter (Vespasian was emphasising that Titus was his intended heir, not Domitian)
• at Vespasian's death, Domitian "toyed with the idea of offering the troops twice as large a bounty as Titus" to take over, and claimed "that his father's will must have been tampered with, since it originally assigned him half the empire" (again shows his insecurity vs Titus, and his ambition to rule
• when Titus was dying, Domitian allegedly neglected him in order to speed up his death (only a rumour but if true shows that he has no qualms about being ruthless and cunning to achieve his own political ends and ambitions)
• Domitian sprent hours alone at the beginning of his reign catching flies and stabbing them with his needle-sharp pen. A joke emerged about him from a senator, Vibius Crispus. When asked whether anyone was closeted with the emperor, he replied "no, not even a fly"
• "for a while he governed in an uneven fashion: that is to say, his vices were at first balanced by his virtues... later, he transformed his virtues into vices too" (hints that there were more admirable aspects of Domitian's reign and conduct, but that these became less frequent over time. The sources don't really mention his 'good' policies
• Cassius Dio
• "Like a thunderbolt, he would often launch devastating attacks upon people, sometimes humiliating the, shamefully, at other times often deliberately inflict physical injuries on them" (conveying that he was quite cruel, a large contrast to his brother and father)
• Also tells us the odd anecdote of Domitian spearing flies with his pen, and the jokes this arose. On this issue, Dio says "this is hardly appropriate material for a serious historical record, but I feel compelled to mention it, both because it is typical behaviour and therefore a useful indication of his character"
• Also tells us the rumour that Domitian hastened Titus' death "rumour has it that he was murdered by his brother, because he had been the target of a previous plot by Domitian. But other sources state that he had fallen ill"
• "Whatever the truth of the story, Domitian rode off to Rome while Titus was still alive, entered the camp of the Praetorian Guard, received the title and powers of the emperor, and gave the soldiers all the same donatives as his brother had done before him". Dio tells us Titus' last words were that he had "one mistake" - either an alleged affair with Domitian's wife, or because he had not had Domitian killed when he was caught plotting against him
• "Other however, suggest (and I incline to agree) that when he caught Domitian manifestly plotting against him, his mistake was not to have killed him, preferring himself to be killed by him instead. In so doing, he had handed over the Roman empire to the sort of man whose character will be revealed in the next chapters of this history"
• "Domitian was aggressive and bad-tempered, but also treacherous and cunning. From the first two characteristics came his impetuosity, from the latter his deviousness"
• "he felt no genuine affection for anyone, except one or two women; but he always put on a great show of affection for anyone whom he most wanted to murder next"
• "he trusted least those who had done him some favour or aided and abetted his most nefarious crimes; as a result, he took care to eliminate anyone who had provided him with generous gifts of cash or given false evidence against large numbers of people, particularly if they were slaves who had laid information of any kind against their masters" (his attitudes towards the Senate are emphasised here - his paranoia led him to re-introduce Maiestas on an unprecedented scale, but as Dio (and elsewhere Suetonius) says he was concerned that by not punishing informers he might encourage their existence. This, however, did not seem to stop him. He took out his paranoia and greed on the Senate - even the informers who informed on other senators were not above suspicion)
• "he once issued an announcement to the effect that any emperor who did not punish informers was himself responsible for encouraging their existence"
• Epitome de Caesaribus
• "he was terrifying for slaughtering the upper classes and began to mete out punishments and, like Gaius Caligula, began to insist on being called 'Lord and God'
• Ridiculously idle, he used to pursue swarms of flies, when everyone had been sent out; disgracefully lustful, he referred to his disgraceful exercise by the Greek term 'wrestling in bed' so when someone was asked whether anyone was in the palace, the reply was "not even a fly"
• The Epitome is a strange summary of Domitian's character (perhaps because it is meant to be an "epitome", a summary) - you can use this source as a way of demonstrating Domitian's legacy, as the Epitome was written centuries after. Being known for "slaughtering the upper classes" says quite a lot, as well as the comparison to Caligula